You know I’ve been lucky enough to see many of the great landmarks of Europe with my own eyes and even sketch them. However I’ve only ever been to New York City outside of Europe. I did manage to sketch quite a few of the city’s landmarks, one of which was the Statue of Liberty. Did you know that it was first opened on 28th October, 1886 – exactly 140 years ago today? Did you also know that it was originally a coppery colour, supposedly inspired by the semi legendary Colossus of Rhodes. (Been there an'all.) The familiar verdigris patina had completely covered the statue by its 40th anniversary, 100 years ago. Yes, I know, I’ve been captured by another little bit of clickbait on my home feed. And now, back to regular programming . . .
Tuesday, 27 October 2026
University Challenge 2027 Repechage 2 - Bristol v. Queen's University, Belfast
The Teams
Bristol
Jake Wingfield
Francesca O’Connor
Freddie Burns (Capt.)
Artem Borisov
Queen’s University, Belfast
Owen Carter
Thomas Dean
Isa Arellano (Capt.)
Noah Calhoun
The first starter twisted and turned like a twisty, turny
thing, losing 5 for Queen’s before the mention of George Gerschwin, Liszt and
Rachmaninov made it clear to Jake Wingfield that we wanted the term Rhapsody. Who
I believe was one of the Angels in Captain Scarlet. You can have that one for
free. Questions on a video game, Clair Obscur got Bristol off to the best
possible start with a full house. “Portrait” and “prominent piece of jewellery”
had to be driving at Girl With A Pearl Earring and it gave Jake Wingfield his
double. A slightly macabre UC special set on the graves of mathematicians saw
Amol give a rather snappy response to the suggestion of Euler for the first. I
hoped we weren’t going to see a repeat of last week’s display from him. Both of
us took just one for the obvious answer of Euclid. Look, I didn’t have a clue
what the next starter was all about – still don’t – but Thomas Dean gave the
correct answer of the Lorentz Factor. Christians in the Mongol Empire brought
two bonuses but Queen’s were let down by their dates of English kings.
Something really tickled Noah Calhoun about the second bonus, but whatever it
was I couldn’t make it out. Come on Noah, share the joke with the whole class,
please. What is represented by the formula for the SI derived unit in the
picture starter? This was actually the answer as well as the question. It works
better if you say it out loud – watt, you see. Jake Wingfield took his third,
knowing that the second Hunger Games book is Catching Fire. Three more SI unit
formulae provided us both with just the one correct answer for lux.
Surprisingly the mention of neighbouring Rawalpindi was not enough to give
either team Islamabad for the next starter. So at the 10 minute mark Bristol
led by 55 – 10.
Glass and navigation tool pointed to the sextant for the
next starter which was taken in an early buzz by Noah Calhoun. Bahamian artist
Tavares Strachan (yes, alright, Tavares Who?) yielded 2 correct answers, but
they missed on Jack Johnson, the man of whom Nat Fleischer once said he was the
only boxer who might have beaten Muhammad Ali in his prime (before his 3 year
ban for refusing to fight in Vietnam) You can have that for free too. Poor Owen
Carter had been just a little buzzer happy in this first half of the contest
and lost five for the third time with a bit of a wild guess. Livonia was enough
for me to guess Latvia while Artem Borisov answered Estonia, both of which
answers were acceptable. The science of colours brought two bonuses. I guessed,
along with Thomas Dean, that the sect referred to in the next question were the
Shakers. (I didn’t immediately launch into a chorus of Shake yer booty – but it
was s struggle). Lakes that have vanished or greatly diminished in size brought
a timely full house to take us up to the music starter. Very quickly Jake
Wingfield identified The Marriage of Figaro. “Of Course!” exclaimed Amol. Yeah,
well, we don’t all have the answers in front of us like you do, mate. Three
more pieces of music whose titles reference Zephir/Zephyr brought two bonuses.
Walled city – and – game – were enough to give Freddie Burns Carcasonne. Baroque
architecture saw Bristol get one bonus – but a single letter robbed them of
two. Amol ruled out Trompe d’oeil for trompe l’oeil and was right to do so. For
the next starter the mention of a book title with the latin for logarithm gave
Freddie Burns John Napier. Literature set in LA in the 1970s brought a full
house to Bristol. Thomas Dean knew the Overton Window for the next starter. We
had some blinds put up by our Overton window last year. Physicists in the RNA
tie club – don’t ask – brought both of us two bonuses and I made my lap of
honour around the sofa while the going was good. This meant that Bristol led
130 – 70 as we approached 20. Just a few minutes earlier the gap had narrowed
to 25 points, but it was widening ominously now.
A beautifully constructed UC special on flags saw Jake
Wingfield first in with Italy. The inaugural Best Album Cover Grammy brought
two bonuses. Fair enough. Noah Calhoun guessed we were seeing a photo of a
golden eagle for the next starter. More birds that are shared as national
symbols by multiple countries brought 1 bonus, although they were nearly there
with the first but said swallowtail rather than swallow. Artem Borisov knew the
word for eggs in Korean cuisine. Phonetics saw Bristol take a full house
leaving them just one full set away from their double century. They didn’t get
it with the next starter for Noah Calhoun correctly buzzed in with algae. A
couple of bonuses on Linus Pauling put Queen’s into triple figures. Freddie
Burns knew that Joseph Wright of Derby painted Vesuvius a lot. Had he never
heard of Etna or Stromboli? Mountain bike challenge races promised but little but
we both got the gimme by knowing the capital of Costa Rica. Thomas Dean knew
that Japan has been governed by the 1955 system. The late Catherine O’Hara
brought just one bonus, but the answer of Schitt’s Creek set my grandson
giggling for the rest of the show. He’s a chip off the old block, that boy. Francesca
O’Connor knew that the first word of ‘Daffodils’ is I. Off the point, Stan Tottman,
one of the best teachers I ever knew, once explained that the first line of
Daffodils encapsulates the romantic movement “I wandered lonely as a cloud” –
and he was right. It really is all there. Innominate parts of the body
(Innominate – de do de do do, Innominate do do do do. etc) brought 1 bonus.
Thomas Dean knew that SG was sublimation. Fair enough. There was time for just
one bonus on islands. Bristol won by 205 – 135.
Bristol deserved their win and achieved a healthy 60.6% bonus
conversion rate. Queen’s BCR was even slightly better, with 63.6%. But you know
the old saying – it’s bonuses for show, but starters for dough.
Amol Watch
We saw an unusually snarky Amol last week. Thankfully that
Amol seems to have put back in his box. Don’t be in a hurry to let hm out again
any time soon, please.
Interesting Fact That I Didn’t Already Know Of
The Week
The swallow is the national bird of both Austria and
Estonia.
Baby Elephant Walk Moment
There were just a couple of times when the internal
orchestra was about to strike up with the familiar dumdums but on these
occasions an early answer put a stop to it, I’m happy to report.
Monday, 26 October 2026
Mastermind 2027 First Round Heat 14
Well, I know what you’ve been worrying about, dearly beloved. Did I manage to get any points on the specialists at all? In the words of the Duke of Wellington himself, it was a damn close run thing. No points on the three subjects offered by our first three contenders, but . . . well, a general knowledge of Hollywood and a guess or two brought me three points on Gene Tierney – I’m perfectly happy to take the money and run with that for tonight.
As for the contenders, well, the contest kicked off with
Gordon Rogers’ round on Creation Records. Now, I think I mentioned this in last
week’s review. You have to know your subject to get as many as 7 points which
is what Gordon managed to do. So nothing to be ashamed of there. But as a score
it does leave you with quite a lot to do and you are vulnerable to other
contenders who don’t just know their subjects, but know them inside out, up and
down and any which way you want to put it.
It looked as if Naomi Liddle might well turn out to be just
such a contender – certainly for the first minute of her round on the X Files.
A couple of questions in the second minute just robbed her of a little momentum
and in the end she just fell a tiny bit short of double figures. Nonetheless,
in the current era a score of 9 is going to leave you well in contention when
the half time oranges are brought out.
Lewis Sinclair’s round was like a mirror image of Naomi’s.
Answering on the Waterloo Campaign, it was his first minute that was less
impressive while a storming comeback in the 2nd minute brought him
right up to his own 9 points. Again, his fate in the show would be in his own
hands in the GK round.
Finishing the round of specialists was retired civil
servant Matin Whitelegge, who thankfully had opted to answer on Gene Tierney.
No, they didn’t ask about the song “24 Hours from Tulsa” since that was Gene
Pitney. Like Naomi and Lewis before him, Martin impressed with his knowledge of
the subject without quite managing to nail down a double figure score. Like the
two aforementioned contenders he too took just the one pass. Were we,
perchance, on the road to another tiebreak?
You have to feel a little sorry for Gordon Rogers. It’s
quite a lonely place when you’re returning to the chair 2 points adrift of 3rd
place, especially when GK is not necessarily your
strongest round. He struggled manfully picking off what he could and in the end
he finished with a total of 13.
Naomi Liddle, on the other hand, did very well on her
return to the chair. We’d been close to a double figure score in three of the
specialists and now Naomi supplied one, then adding another GK point for 11 and a
total of 20. Whatever happened in the rest of the show, she’d earned a score
which would have won several of the other heats. Is that a comfort ? Well, I
didn’t think so in 2006 when I was on the wrong end of it, but enough of such
things for now.
I have to say that I really enjoyed Lewis Sinclair’s
General Knowledge round. You watch these rounds, and you see a contender start
to build up a good score, and you’re always a little worried that they’re going
to run out of steam and tail off a bit. Lewis didn’t. After a minute he looked
likely to beat the target and after two minutes he almost had. After two and a
half minutes he’d scored a very fine 13 to set the target at 22.
It would have been tempting fate to suggest that Martin
might have given us a third consecutive double figure round. Whether he had
been affected by the two preceding rounds I don’t know, but he never really got
into his stride and added 7 to finish with 16.
Well done Lewis! Scores in the teens on a single round have
been pretty sparse in the series so far. So thank you very much for that. I do
wish you every success in the semi-finals – with GK like that you’re always
going to be in with a shout. Very hard lines to Naomi. Take heart from a good
performance and the knowledge that you were good enough to have won quite a few of the other heats.
The Details
|
Gordon Rogers |
Creation Records |
7 |
1 |
6 |
1 |
13 |
2 |
|
Naomi Liddle |
The X Files |
9 |
1 |
11 |
2 |
20 |
3 |
|
Lewis Sinclair |
The Waterloo Campaign |
9 |
1 |
13 |
0 |
22 |
1 |
|
Martin Whitelegge |
Gene Tierney |
9 |
1 |
7 |
3 |
16 |
4 |
Sunday, 25 October 2026
Mastermind Heat 14 Specialist Subjects
Sorry that I didn’t get around to posting this yesterday, peeps. So, tonight’s Mastermind specialist subjects will be:-
Creation Records
The X Files
The Waterloo Campaign
Gene Tierney
Once again I feel nothing but gloom about my prospects of a
decent aggregate. I know nothing about Creation Records. I know hardly much
more about Gene Tierney – although I do like 24 Hours from Tulsa. (I know.)
Maybe there’s a point or two on Waterloo, though I know more about the station
and much more about the bridge. Again, I used to watch the X-Files but not as
more than a casual viewer from time to time. I’d like to think I won’t get
zero, but it’s nothing I’d want to put money on.
Saturday, 24 October 2026
Good Quiz at the Club
You may well have noticed that I am not exactly complimentary about the other question setters/masters at the rugby club who aren’t in my team. I will concede that it’s mean – none of us pretend to be professional question setters/quiz hosts (although I have accepted payment for setting questions in the past and could probably be persuaded to do so again.) All we get for doing so is a few free drinks. But, I don’t know. It’s not exactly rocket science, putting together a decent quiz. Yet the other setters at the quiz with the exception of Dan, Jess and Adam just fall into such easily avoidable traps – asking too many guess a number questions – not checking the answer they have is correct – not taking enough care over the phrasing of the questions – asking things which are just not interesting. I will give some credit to Dai – and not just because he has been known to read the blog – but I like his quizzes more than the others. Damning with faint praise, I know.
So, having said all of that, it’s a pleasure to say that we
had a quiz at the club on Thursday night which I enjoyed every bit as much as
the quizzes set by Jess, Dan and Adam. Our new question master was Claire. I’ve
known Claire for a long time – she used to come to the quiz with my pal Robert
Merrill and play for the Lemurs – the team who used to beat us more often than
we beat them. I don’t recall her writing the quiz before. But it was just such
a pleasure to play in a quiz which seemed to have been written by someone who
has a clear idea what a good question sounds like, and what makes a good quiz.
I don’t think I once responded to any of the questions with words to the effect
of – what the ‘ell’s she asking that for? - . It was a very good quiz and I
hope she’ll take her place on the regular setters’ roster. And maybe give a few
tips to some of the other setters. . . Just saying.
Tuesday, 20 October 2026
University Challenge 2027 Repechage Round - ST. John's Cambridge v. London School of Economics
The Teams
St. John’s Cambridge
Callum Thomas
Jonathan Watts
Liam Plimmer (Capt)
Aurelia Walker
London School of Economics
David Worley
Diya Khatri
Henry Jameson (Capt)
Daniel Yang
What, repechage round already? Yes indeed. On paper these
were two very evenly matched teams – St. John’s scoring 170 in round 1, while
LSE scored 160. However the BCRs of the teams suggested a different story. St.
John’s was 70.6% while the LSE had a BCR of 46%. All of which suggested that if
St. John’s could achieve parity on the buzzer, then they looked the most likely
winners.
Skipper Liam Plimmer got St. John’s going, knowing that
Goethe and Schiller in the same question suggested Weimar. Wei not?
Representation and democracy did not seem to be doing anyone favours until the
quotation from Lincoln’s Gettysburg address brought us both one bonus. Both
teams sat on their buzzer for the next starter, until the mention on Van Dyke (Anthony,
not Dick) made it clear that the royal collector had to be Charles I. Henry
Jameson opened the LSE account with this. Bonuses on cakes and pastries in
Victorian novels - they missed a trick by not asking about Kipling here, I would have thought - were not actually about the cakes or pastries at all in the
first two questions. They were just a different way of asking – in which novels
do Mrs. Tulliver and Esther Summerson appear? LSE didn’t know, although they
did get the third which was the only one really about cakes and pastries. A
literary starter followed, with various Daisys (Renton, Miller and Buchanan)
giving Liam Plimmer the answer. Birds with names linked to war was a lovely and
really rather informative set, from which St. John’s took a full house. I had
never linked sniper with snipe before, even though it sounds obvious once you
know. For the first picture starter Henry Jameson recognised a printed recipe
for a Singapore sling. More cocktails featuring the names of nationalities or
countries in their official names brought just one bonus. Callun Thomas
recognised references to indigo dye for the next starter. English towns and
cities beginning with B and ending with Ford brought two bonuses. This meant
that on ten minutes St. John’s led by 60 -30 and were having the better of the
buzzer races.
Having said that it was a very good early buzz that saw
Daniel Yang identifying that Japan left the League of Nations in 1933. Notable
goals at the 2025 Women’s European Football Championships saw a welcome name
check for Hanwell’s Chloe Kelly, the only answer either of us got. Nobody got
Robert ‘Who?’ Merton for the next starter. You had to wait and wait with the
next starter – LSE didn’t and so lost five – but eventually ‘a walled city on
the Black Sea’ was enough to suggest Baku. Callum Thomas took that. Recent
recipients of the Charlemagne Prize yielded a good full house. A lap of honour
came my way for immediately guessing that the K in KIE stood for Kinetic in the
next starter. Aurelia Walker had that one. James Prescott Joule (nicknamed
‘Uncut’ by his mates, I believe) refused to yield any bonus points. For the
music starter Diya Khatri recognised the dulcet tones of the La’s singing There
she Goes. There you go. More songs used in The Gilmore Girls didn’t bring any
points, but it did bring a hell of a lot of frustration for Daniel Yang who
just couldn’t dredge up the name of the Bangles. All of which was compounded by
a rather snarky remark from Amol. A long winded description of tooth decay fell
to Callum Thomas. Greek mythology is often a fruitful subject on UC and so it
was for St. John’s, providing a full house. Liam Plimmer knew that Sonia Knips
was painted by Klimt (2 coats of whitewash and then rubbed down with a copy of
the Sporting Life, I believe) Fish and ways of cooking it brought just the one
bonus. Liam Plimmer knew that the next starter was talking about badminton but
couldn’t quite dredge up shuttlecock for the next starter which allowed Diya
Khatri to take the points. Bob Dylan’s The Girl from the North Country (an ode to Elsie Tanner, by any chance?) brought
a couple of bonuses, but St. John’s led by 130-60 on 20 minutes.
For the second picture starter Callum Thomas identified politician
Lula da Silva. Other recipients of the Grand Collar Order of Camoes for
services to Portuguese took them to 145, and they looked about to cross the
event horizon. Aurelia Walker worked out that the various clues in the next
starter pointed to the colour red. I believe that the next bonus set may have
been linked by the theme of chemical gobbledygook. I didn’t get any, while St.
John’s got two. Moving swiftly on Henry Jameson recognised a reference to Twain
(I think it was Mark, but might have been Shania) and the phrase Gilded Age. Terms
for Church windows brought two bonus in short order. Henry Jameson also knew
two rivers in Bangladesh for the next starter. Things in the natural world
whose common names are used poetically as synonyms for black saw them take just
the one from a pretty gettable set. Jonathan Watts knew several species of
gibbons, although ‘funky’ and Stanley’ were not among those mentioned. Works in
philosophy and the social sciences from the first decade of the 20th
century brought two bonuses and the double century looked on the cards for St.
John’s. I understood the next starter relating author’s names to chemical
elements but I didn’t know who wrote the Neapolitan Quartet (the Neapolitan
trilogy of course being vanilla, chocolate and strawberry). Callum Thomas
worked it all out and gave the correct answer of Iron. SI base units are hardy
perennials on UC and St. John’s gathered a full harvest. Henry Jameson got his
fourth and fifth French Republics mixed up and this allowed Liam Plimmer in for
another starter. Events of 1924 in the USA didn’t add any gloss to their score,
but it was all academic by this stage. David Worley won the buzzer race to answer
Charleston for the next starter. There was no time left for bonuses, thpugh.
St. John’s won by 220 – 100.
St. John’s were the better of these two teams on the night.
They achieved a BCR of 58.3% this time to LSE’s 33.3%.
Amol Watch
“I don’t think I’d have forgiven you if you got that one
wrong” said Amol to St. John’s about the Gettysburg address question. This was
just an early example of the rather bumptious mood he seemed to be in for this show. Maybe it was filmed just after he was first to be kicked out of The Traitors. He then
rather condescendingly told LSE he would accept Alice in Wonderland even though
the official title is Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. When Daniel Yang
couldn’t dredge up The Bangles he rubbed it in with “Never mind. We enjoyed
watching you struggle.” What had rubbed Amol up the wrong way before the show,
one can only ask. Even at the end he had another little dig – “you gave us such
wonderful entertainment in the bonuses, having these feverish discussions then
getting them wrong.” Oh, come on, Amol. This is not big and it’s not clever.
Interesting Fact That I Didn’t Already Know Of
The Week
The bird on the flag of Kiribati is a frigate bird. I don’t know how I’ve never known that before, but I’m glad to know it now.
Baby Elephant Walk Moment
Smooth surface, pit and fissure, and root are three main
types of what condition caused by exposure to acidic substances produced by
bacteria? The last of these types is more common in older people, because the
area exposed is more . . . (incorrect interruption) vulnerable lacking the hard
protective surface known as enamel. – Yeah, it wasn’t the most difficult to
understand, but surely didn’t need to be so long winded. Dum de dumdum dum dum
dum dum dumdum.
Monday, 19 October 2026
Mastermind 2027 First Round Heat 13
Well, dearly beloved, I did predict that I wasn’t going to get many points in the specialists in tonight’s show and I was certainly right about that. 1 from Peep Show and 1 from the Lake District as it happens.
First up was Matt Malin. He offered us Peep Show. I was
always more of a casual viewer than a regular but I did catch one or two of
them at times. It didn’t help me. Matt scored 7. We’ve seen a lot of contenders
during the series who all knew their subject, and I’d put Matt in this
category, but not quite in enough depth to be able to reach a really commanding
total. It takes a hell of a lot of focussed preparation and revision, I can
tell you.
Emily Freeman was answering on the subject about which I
knew least, probably because I’d never even heard of Aemilia Lanyer before the
subjects for this show were announced. Again, Emily knew her stuff, but again,
not quite in the depth needed to give yourself a realistic chance. Sh too
scored 7 and I was beginning to wonder whether we had another of those heats
where there is something in the air that limits the scoring.
Maria Nagle made a good start with Joni Mitchell and she
scored quite well throughout the round. As it was, only an unlucky close but no
cigar answer to the last question prevented her from a good 9. Nonetheless, 8
was enough to put her into the lead with one contender still to go.
This contender was Tony Barnes. Tony was answering on The
Lake District. I often feel that such a wide subject as this should carry a
government health warning. Once again, Tony obviously knew his stuff, but it
seems such a catch all subject that there were aspects of it he maybe hadn’t
considered which is probably why he too scored 8.
Would the ‘something in the air’ I’ve speculated about continue
to affect the scores as we headed into the General Knowledge rounds? Time would
tell. Matt Malin came back and he delivered the highest scoring round of the
night so far with 9. This boosted him to 16. If you’d asked before the start of
the show whether I thought that 16 could be a winning total I would have said
it was unlikely. After the specialists though, it looked more possible.
Poor Emily Freeman never really managed to get to grips
with her GK round. She gave it a lash, but in the end she could only take her
total up to 12.
Maria Nagle only needed to match Matt’s 9 points to take he
lead. She too gave it a lash, but in the same way you often see track athletes
tightening up as they enter the home straight, so Maria just couldn’t quite
maintain the momentum to get herself over the line before time was up. She
scored 7 to finish with 15. No cigar I’m afraid.
So it was all down to Tony. He too scored 7 for 15,
although I would say that he didn’t run out of steam so much as never quite had
the momentum he needed throughout the whole round.
So Matt Malin achieved the rare feat of going first in the last
round, and hanging on to win the show. Best of luck in the semis.
Right, please do not take this comment as an intended
criticism of any of tonight’s contenders – it is not meant that way. But last
week, all 4 contenders scored more highly than any of tonight’s. I’m not saying
that Matt does not deserve his place in the semi final. Of course he does! It
always has been you win a heat and you go through and it always should be. But
surely, surely it’s time to go back to recognising exceptional performance by
runners up by awarding a couple of wild cards through to the semis.
It’s a lot fairer on the viewers, if you want my opinion.
The Details
|
Matt Malin |
Peep Show |
7 |
2 |
9 |
2 |
16 |
4 |
|
Emily Freeman |
Aemilia Lanyer |
7 |
2 |
5 |
6 |
12 |
8 |
|
Maria Nagle |
Joni Mitchell |
8 |
0 |
7 |
3 |
15 |
3 |
|
Tony Barnes |
The Lake DIstrict |
8 |
1 |
7 |
1 |
15 |
2 |
Sunday, 18 October 2026
Mastermind 2027 first Round Heat 13 Preview
Tomorrow night’s specialist subjects are:-
The TV comedy series Peep Show
English poet Aemilia Lanyer
The singer-songwriter Joni Mitchell
The Lake District.
A quick search on LAM reveals that since LAM started Peep
Show has been a semi final subject in both 2023 and 2018 and a first round
subject in 2013. I doubt I got many on any of those rounds and I doubt I’ll get
many tomorrow night. That goes for the other subjects too. Aemilia Lanyer was a
contemporary of Shakespeare (there is no evidence that she was the ‘Dark Lady’
of his sonnets) but I only know that because I just googled her name. I know
what everyone knows about Joni Mitchell but that really isn’t a lot. I think
that the Lake District has been a subject a couple of times in the last 10
years – again, I don’t expect many points.
Tuesday, 13 October 2026
More Thoughts on 1977
Received wisdom tells us that Mastermind was better in Magnus’ day, doesn’t it? I’ll be honest, I did think that BBC were playing with fire a bit by showing the 1977 series on BBC4 just a couple of hours after the current series on BBC2. I’ve watched every episode of the 77 series as each has been shown. So the question we should ask is – is the classic series REALLY that much better than the current version?
Well, first of all, let’s leave behind fripperies like the
odd fashions and hairstyles. Those in 1977 weren’t much better either. Boom
boom. But joking aside, let’s try to concentrate on the show itself.
One clear difference is the 2x2 format of the rounds in the
old series. I always preferred this even split of two rounds of two minutes’
duration each. 1-0 to the classic series. Now, you’d think that the 1970s
questions are a clear advantage over the modern day questions. Well, they were
certainly less long winded than the questions that get asked nowadays, yes. The
lengthy questions are a major gripe with the show in the current era. But at
least . . . at least the questions in the current era are for the huge
majority, written with precision. They make you either give a wrong answer or a
right answer – they don’t allow for much grey area and I personally feel that
this is how it should be. I have been struck by how vague some of the questions
in 1977 were. In fact I have gone so far as to call some of them quite poorly
written – speaking as a question setter of pretty long standing myself. In
every show, it seems, Magnus was called upon to exercise judgement over whether
a contender had got the gist of the answer. Well, getting the gist is not good
enough. So what the old series wins on the volume of questions, it loses on the
imprecise nature of so many of them. Score draw.
What about the contenders? On this very blog, I’ve made the
point that the talent pool in the
current era is shallow, and too thinly spread. Well, judging by what I’ve seen
in the 1977 series so far, the average contender was no better in 77 than they
are today. Yes, they score more points, but only it would seem because they get
asked more questions. The 1977 series was considerably shorter than the 31 show
series of the modern programme, so maybe the talent appeared a little more
thickly spread because it didn’t have to be spread quite so far. I can only
speculate on the difference in quiz culture 49 years ago. I don’t know how many
quiz leagues there were back in the day and I don’t know if pub quizzes – if
indeed they existed – were anything like as popular and plentiful as they are
today. I was around in 77 but I was only 13. Even back in the 70s, pub going at
that age was frowned upon. However, quiz shows were surely as much a staple on
TV back in those days as they are today.
An obvious point of comparison is in the kinds of subjects
being offered for specialist round. The 1977 subjects seem more consciously
highbrow for want of a better term. In many cases they seem a lot wider as
well. I have found that this can make it a little harder to really get a
feeling for just how well a contender really knows their subject and how well
they seem to have prepared. I have no intention of accusing any contender of
skimping on their preparation in my reviews, but I do feel you can usually tell
who hasn’t put the work in– and this isn’t just a matter of seeing who had the
lowest scores either.
For many of those of us of a certain age, Mastermind WAS
Magnus Magnusson. I loved him as a question master and in the years since the
original series came to an end it was gratifying to see just how many people
who met him and who knew him paid tribute to what a warm, funny, good guy he
was. ‘nice’ is a word that loses a lot of currency when you apply it to people
but personally I think it’s one of the best things you can say about someone. I
spoke in my mum’s funeral last week, and I unashamedly made the point that she
was a really, genuinely nice person. She was too. However – and I’m feeling a
little bit of a heel for saying this- I have been surprised on the number of
fluffs Magnus made in certain shows.
Of course, in my own experience the production teams have
been quite zealous about reshooting and ironing out the bumps in the modern
series. As for the presenters, well, I always felt with John Humphrys that
taking part in 6 shows with him never really constituted an introduction. I
knew him no better the last time I met him than I did the first time. But, when
he got in the studio, he was a thorough professional, I have to give him that.
Likewise, today’s Clive Myrie does a thoroughly professional job as well. More
than that I can’t say, never having met him.
If we move to more intangible things, the atmosphere in
both shows is more different than I would have expected. For all the formality
– in 1977 the contenders were all dressed very formally and each was either
‘Mr.’, ‘Mrs.’ or ‘Miss’, the show seemed somehow a little more intimate than
the current series. Contenders’ Row was closer to the black chair. The lighting
was a little more natural, without so much of the bright spotlit interrogation
of the modern series. Magnus did not try to oversell the drama or artificially
build the tension like poor old Clive does – Why are they here? I hear you ask?
What is it that persuades ordinary upstanding members of the public to
volunteer to face the ordeal of the black chair. Is it masochism? Is it hubris?
Is it a combination of both? Do any of you give a rat’s doodah? Etc. etc by
which time I’m yelling ‘get on with it, Clive! On the other hand Clive doesn’t
have to tell us “We come to you tonight from the Great Hall of St. Angreevsey’s
Academy for the sons of smarmy gentlefolk in Shrewsbury, founded in 1562 by the
grandfather of Guy Fawkes, Sir Arbuthnot ‘Tuning’ Fawkes. The school’s motto is
taken from the family motto of the Fawkes family, which is “Lawks a Lordy, my
bottom’s on fire.”
I think that the most honest assessment I can make is to
say that despite being essentially the same show, they are pretty different and
it’s actually more hard to make a compelling case that one version is much
better than the other. What the audience
of 1977 would make if suddenly taken by TARDIS and brought to the recording of
the modern show – well, that really would be interesting.
University Challenge 2027 First Round SOAS v. Edinburgh
The Teams
SOAS
Josephine Newcombe
Seb Lawson
Lola Finch (capt)
Aidan Langston
Edinburgh
Daniel Bloom
Caitlin Tambini
Fred Whibley (capt)
Siddhant Kumar
London’s School of Oriental and African Studies have passed
this way before – not as many times as Edinburgh – but at least they’re not
strangers to the competition.
First blood fell to Aidan Langston, recognising a group of
words, each beginning with bis. 20th century history brought two
bonuses. SOAS’ Seb Lawson, who was going to have a most productive evening,
took the first of his starters knowing that Wimbledon’s Crazy Gang defeated
Liverpool in the 1988 Cup Final (Lawrie Sanchez goal won it). I’ve lived in
Wales for 40 years, but have never before heard of the Seven (so called )
Wonders of Wales but two of them were easy for us to guess, the same two that
SOAS took. Keen to halt the SOAS charge, Edinburgh captain Fred Whibley buzzed
early for the next starter and got the correct answer with third. The bonuses
for you, then Edinburgh, announced Amol, are on the control of gene expression.
I think my exact expression when he announced this was – oh, bloody hell. Which
should make me feel slightly guilty for the fact that I had a full house
because of the very helpful clues given at the end of each of the questions.
Edinburgh took 2 and I set off on my wheezy lap of honour around the sofa.
Every year I think I can’t get any slower and every year I prove myself wrong. For
the picture starter we saw a flag representing the office of president of a
country. Nobody, me included, knew it was Cuba. Fred Whibley tried another
interruption on the next starter but unsuccessfully. Given the whole question
he’d have known the answer required was St. Elmo’s Fire – the weather
phenomenon, not the song nor the brat pack movie it was taken from. Aidan Langston
had that. More presidential flags brought two correct answers – I only had
Botswana. (If you have Botswana, try a little ointment to help clear it up).
The next starter gave us the first line of Thomas Hardy’s gagfest “Jude the
Obscure”. The mention of Christminster in the question gave Seb Lawson what he
needed to take a second starter. Characters whose names appear in novels with
title and surname, eg Mr. Hyde, saw SOAS take two, and just miss out on Mr.
Norrell from the excellent Susanna Clarke novel “Jonathan Strange and Mr.
Norrell”. Nonetheless it had been a fine first 10 minutes for SOAS who led by 80-10
Seb Lawson started the middle 10 the way he had ended the
first, correctly answering that Frankfurt is the home of the European Central
Bank for his third starter. Philosophical zombies – nope, me neither – conjured
up some strange mental images and also two correct answers for SOAS. Poor Siddhant
Kumar took a flier on the next starter and was a little unlucky to get his
water pump mixed up with his vacuum pump. This gave Seb Lawson his 4th
starter. SOAS took 1 bonus on alloys and should probably have had the old quiz
chestnut, amalgam for another. You had to wait with the next starter for it to
become obvious. Edinburgh understandably didn’t and unfortunately lost five. Seb
Lawson did and took his fifth starter with John Wycliffe. Grammatical aspects
of verbs meant nowt to me – well, be fair, I only taught English for 37 years –
but brought a couple more correct answers to SOAS, whose lead was now over 100
points. A fine buzz from Daniel Bloom brought an early correct answer to the
music starter as he recognised the work of Siouxsie and the Banshees. (Their
Dear Prudence is probably my favourite Beatles cover) Other works that sample
songs by them brought 1 bonus. Gawd knows why, when the next starter mentioned
‘which brand of physics’ I said thermodynamics, but Siddhant Kumar did the same
and we were both right. Central Asian History brought just the one bonus
although they did throw one away when the correct answer had been very much on
the table. Daniel Bloom was on a roll though and took the next starter with the
term ‘calque’. Animals whose names are part of the name of teams in the NHL brought
two bonuses. SOAS didn’t panic, though, and the words ‘painter’ and ‘yellow
house’ were enough to give Seb Lawson a 6th starter with Vincent Van
Gogh. People born in 1825 yielded two bonuses and the revelation that Darwin’s
bulldog, Thomas Huxley, was born in my home borough of Ealing! Yay. Skipper
Lola Finch knew the term diegetic for the next starter. Atypical instruments
used in works of classical music brought another two bonuses. This meant that
on the cusp of the 20 minute mark SOAS led by 175 – 45. Game over? Probably.
Edinburgh were still leaping to the buzzer, though and
Daniel Bloom was very quickly into identify a wee bit of Rousseau for the
second picture starter. Two bonuses on paintings of storms followed. Seb Lawson’s
7th starter identified Frederick the Great. The chemistry of
painkillers brought a bonus, and only a very slight mispronunciation robbed
them of one more. A good buzz from Siddhant Kumar linked Kekule – whose chief
claim to fame was almost being an anagram of ukulele – with the word ouroboros.
Publications linked by the word crisis brought a bonus. Nigerian writer looked likely to be Wole
Soyinka or Chinua Achebe – Seb Lawson zigged with Soyinka, but he shoulda zagged
with Achebe. I didn’t get enough of the next question to understand it but
Daniel Bloom knew the answer was zakat. Decades of the 11th century
brought just one bonus. Would they quite get to triple figures, I wondered. Well,
Seb Lawson took starter 8 knowing beta carotene is a precursor to vitamin a. SI
Derived units and elements were a nice UC special set but brought just one
bonus. Didn’t matter, it was all gilding by this point. Aidan Langton knew that
a language is a dialect with an army and a navy for the next starter. Two
bonuses on pink were taken. Seb Lawson completed a haul of 9 starters knowing
Krakatoa is in Indonesia (although not East of Java). Tone poems brought just 5
more points. My grandson was tickled pink to hear that the first tank was
nicknamed Little Willie – he has inherited his old Grampa’s schoolboy sense of
humour I’m afraid – but nobody had it. GOOONNNGGGG! SOAS won by 240 – 80.
With a bonus conversion rate of 56.4% to Edinburgh’s 42.8%
it’s clear that SOAS were the better team in both buzzing and bonuses, and may
well be worth an each way bet at this stage of the competition. Me? Sorry, no,
with my tipping track record the Clark 50p is staying glued in my pocket. Even
if SOAS swore to have wrapped Seb Lawson in cotton wool and given him a 24 hour
bodyguard between matches.
Amol Watch
Can’t say anything caught the eye particularly tonight.
Interesting Fact That I Didn’t Already Know Of
The Week
The phrase St. Elmo’s Fire derives from an Italian
corruption of the name of the patron saint of mediterranean sailors.
Baby Elephant Walk Moment
Conversely, what term is used for a region of DNA
immediately upstream of a gene that facilitates binding of RNA polymerase, therefore
initiating transcription? The same word is used generally for a person who
organises or supports an event. Dum de dumdum dum dum dum dum dumdum.
Monday, 12 October 2026
Mastermind 2027 First Round Heat 12
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is what you get when you don’t have any repechage slots in your series. But I fear I’m getting ahead of myself.
First into the lists was Kieran James answering on my
banker subject, JRR Tolkein’s Lord of the Rings. I scored 5 on this set, but I
reckon that Kieran has read the books far many more times than I have, for he
answered every question correctly and I reckon he could have gone on doing so
all night. In fact the only way you could criticise the round is that his
answers were just a little measured which prevented him getting in a 13th
question. Exceptional performance, still.
Teacher Lydia Dias had support from the Clark sofa to
overcome (yeah, alright, I’m well out of the classroom now and I ain’t never
goin’ back, but I still want to see my brethren and sistren doing well) And doing
well is something Lydia did. Answering at top speed she ot through 13 questions
in total and it was a surprise that she only managed 11 of them. Only! It was a
great performance and meant she would be well in contention.
Sadly Mark Hamid could not do the same with Foyle’s War. I
don’t really know what went wrong with the round for Mark, but sometimes when
it rains, it pours. I picked up 3 points with guesses on Jitterbug, Gone With
the Wind and Rembrandt – all of which went begging for Mark. But it’s a shame,
and he did look rather crestfallen on his return to contenders’ row.
Finally Joe Gellman, who was answering on the PDC world
darts championship. 1 point took my aggregate to 9, with which I was delighted
and happy to take the points and run. Joe had prepared thoroughly and gave us
our third double figure round of the night, finishing with 10.
So to the GK round. Mark Hamid returned to the chair and
delivered a thoroughly splendid round of 12. That’s class. You couldn’t help thinking
about what might have been had he only had a better specialist round. Certainly
worth your while thinking about having another try in the future Mark, for what
it’s worth.
Here’s a thought for you. In the whole show tonight only
two of the rounds did not score double figures. Mark’s specialist was one and
Joe Gellman’s GK was the other. Mind you, he came pretty close, scoring 9 to
give himself a total of 19. In terms of what we’ve already seen this series,
that’s a good score and wherever he finished Joe could be well satisfied with
his evening’s work.
As could Lydia Dias. From what I’ve already said you know
that she achieved a double points round. What I haven’t said yet though is that
this wasn’t just a double figure round, but a round in the teens. Yes, it
looked like Lydia had a few guesses, but that’s the thing you see. A good
quizzer will guess, but guess more accurately than others would. 24 is one of
the highest totals this series so far. If Kieran was going to beat it, he was
going to have to do it the hard way.
In fact, Kieran didn’t beat it. He scored 12 and 1 pass to
equal Lydia’s score and this gave us a tie break. Which was fine by me,, as
this was a contest to savour. In the end, given the same 5 questions Mark
scored 4 to Lydia’s 3. Congratulations, sir. You have marked yourself out as a
frontrunner in the current series and I really wish you the very best of luck
in the semis. As for Lydia, I can only commiserate. This was the best
performance from a teacher since John Robinson won 2 years ago. You were
brilliant.
As for the people who make the show. We have seen a total
of 15 win a heat in this series which beings an automatic place in the semi
final. We have now seen a total of 24 which does not bring an automatic semi
final place. I don’t know how much more clearly I can say this. There is not
enough talent in the contender pool that you can afford to weaken the semi
finals by not having one or two places for highest scoring runners up like
Lydia. It was glaringly obvious last year. It is glaringly obvious this year. Please.
The Details
|
Kieran James |
JRR Tolkien |
12 |
0 |
12 |
1 |
24 |
1 |
4 |
|
Lydia Dias |
Talking Heads |
11 |
0 |
13 |
1 |
24 |
1 |
3 |
|
Mark Hamid |
Foyle’s War |
5 |
0 |
12 |
0 |
17 |
0 |
|
|
Joe Gellman |
The PDC World Darts
CHampionship |
10 |
0 |
9 |
0 |
19 |
0 |
|