Heads up peeps. I’ve just been over to the BBC Mastermind website. The specialists for the last of this year’s semi finals will be:-
Amelia Earhart
Sir Laurence Olivier
The red wines of Burgundy
The songs of Sir Noël Coward.
I have to be honest, on a personal level it’s hard to call
any of them a banker subject. I suppose that I have more chance of getting one
or two right on Sir Laurence Olivier, but with the others it will be a matter
of pure luck whether something I can guess the answer to comes up.
On another level I looked at the photograph of tomorrow
night’s line up and it didn’t look as if Dennis Wang was among them. On one
level it’s good if it means that everyone who won a heat got to experience a
semi final. On another level though, I can’t help feeling sorry that we are in
an era of the show without repechages. I do feel that the talent is thinly enough spread as it is.
So I’ve had a think about this. Earlier this year I
suggested my option 1 - that we make a series of 29 shows. We do 22 heats and then
the two highest scoring runners up get wild cards through to the semis. But
then maybe there’s a reason why the Beeb need the series to comprise of 31
shows. If this is a case then I have an option 2 as a compromise. We do 23 heats. This will
provide 23 contenders for 24 slots in the semis. Then we have a repechage for
the 4 highest scoring runners up, with the winner becoming the 24th semi-finalist. I
don’t like it as much as option 1 because it would mean that the contender who
wins the repechage would have to learn 4 subjects throughout the series if they
won the semi final. But then, in 2006 when I was a highest scoring runner
up in the heats when there was no
repechage, if you’d offered me the chance to do something like this I would
have bitten your hand off to take the opportunity.
I reiterate that I would not like to see Mastermind turn
away from tournament play. I would not like to see the top six performers from
the heats go straight through to the finals, which is what happened with Sport
Mastermind. But we can tweak things so that we don’t lose potential finalists
because fate has placed them a freakishly strong heat.
As always, just my opinion. Feel free to disagree.
No comments:
Post a Comment