Tuesday, 28 October 2025

University Challenge 2026 - Repechage 2 - Sheffield v. New College

The Teams

Sheffield

Rhys Lewis

Abdelrahman Elsisi

Jacob Price (Capt)

Isobel Dobbie

New College, Oxford

Benji Stimpson

Paige Crawley

Jonah Poulard (Capt.)

Daan Timmers

Last of the two repechage matches, then. The form book said Sheffield, but then the form book should always be treated with a little scepticism.

For the first starter we had to wait and wait until it became obvious the answer required was Lost World. New College miscued with Lost City which allowed Abdelrahman Elsisi in with the right answer. National flags on which stars represent islands brought a great full house – it’s one thing when you can see the flags but when they are just described to you it's quite another. Paige Crawley came in too early for the second starter in a row, allowing Isobel Dobbie to identify a description of the word propaganda. Listed buildings used as locations in Avengers films revealed that one of the locations was Sainsburys, although it didn’t say which branch. Sheffield only took one of this set. Benji Stimpson wiped out the New College deficit with the answer ‘steady state’ for the next starter. A full house on the absurd was swiftly taken. Jonah Poulard capitalised by recognising the location of Naples for the first picture starter. Three more locations recognised by Unesco for culinary heritage saw a welcome name check for famous Argentinian born revolutionary Fray Bentos (see The Office) but only 1 was correctly answered. After a Sheffield miscue, Jonah Poulard identified Charles Rennie Mackintosh being associated with Glasgow. Responses to war by female artists yielded one correct answer. This meant that they had come back after a shaky start and led by 45-35 on 10 minutes.

A lead which grew after Jonah Poulard buzzed in very early to identify the word hero linking the titles of several works. New College rather threw away a correct answer on muscles by giving the answer trapezoid rather than trapezius which was actually required. It’s a shame because they did have the other two. However on the next starter the New College skipper came in too early and lost five, allowing opposite number Jacob Price in with the answer of Schengen. I’m not familiar with the work of Paul Auster nor, I think, are Sheffield. However they guessed one of them. Sheffield now incurred their second penalty for an early buzz allowing Paige Crawley in to identify Greece. Confucius proved a bit confucing to New College, who managed just the one bonus. For the music starter Benji Stimpson was in very early to identify the tones of Pete Seeger. Other artists who regularly appeared on some musicologist’s 1940s radio show saw some interesting guesses from New College, but they were at least right with Woody Guthrie. Abdelrahman Elsisi was first to identify the Nicobar pigeon as one of the closest living relatives of the dodo. Winners at the 2024 Peabody Awards which celebrate outstanding public service – no, I’m surprised I wasn’t nominated too, now you mention it – yielded one bonus. Rhys Lewis took his first starter identifying the Gregorian chant Dies Irae. Whatever lights your candle. Lev Landau’s genius scale – beats working for a living, I spose – brought me a lap of honour for knowing Paul Dirac which could have become two laps when I identified Heisenberg for the third. Sheffield also took a pair. Abdelrahman Elsisi knew a group of Roman Emperors whose names all began with G-A -L. Gallopingourmus was apparently not one of them. Sheffield managed one of a set of gettable bonuses on the openings of Dickens novels, which was enough to give them a narrow lead of 95 – 90 on 20 minutes.

Isobel Dobbie was in very quickly for the second picture starter to identify the work of one of my favourite artists, Caravaggio. Other depictions of the story of Echo and Narcissus brought a timely full house. All 8 contenders were too young to have heard of the Gleneagles agreement for the next starter. Jonah Poulard knew that Trignav is the tallest mountain in Slovenia and the subsequent bonuses on dumplings brought their own full house. The match was still too close to call. Paige Crawley restored her team’s lead with Jibril of the angel Gabriel. 2 bonuses on dentistry were taken. Isobel Dobbie identified the artist John Singer Sargent . Two bonuses on Greek mythology restored the lead to Sheffield. Benji Stimpson’s twitchy buzzer finger cost five points for the next starter which was compounded as Jacob Price correctly identified Diego Garcia. Smaller locations in England whose names include – burgh – brought one bonus. This meant New College needed an unanswered full house to draw level. Jonah Poulard took a flier but couldn’t make it stick with the next starter which penalty meant that New College were going to need at least 2 visits to the table. Abdelrahman Elsisi more or less sealed the deal knowing the Afro-Asian language family. Bonuses on the old Bafta or most promising newcomer. I loved Abdelrahman Elsisi suggestion that Judi Dench might have received the Best Newcomer BAFTA for Bugsy Malone. Didn’t matter. There was daylight between the teams and little time left. Jacob Price knew the word ‘cometh’ – as in The Iceman Cometh – an early play about the X Men, I believe. Words only used once in Shakespeare yielded nowt. That was that. Sheffield won by 175 – 125.

For the record Sheffield earned a BCR of 45% while New College looked better with 58%, but that was on top of 5 penalties, which helped keep Sheffield in the game until their power charge kicked in.

Amol Watch

When New College managed to get the last of the music bonuses right, “Thank goodness you got that one!” responded Amol. Gotta be honest, that’s not the nicest reaction, Amol. Smacks of saying – I can’t believe you didn’t get the others. We can do without that.

Interesting Fact That I Didn’t Already Know Of The Week

Joe Pesci won the best newcomer BAFTA for Raging Bull. To be honest I thought he might have been around for longer.

Baby Elephant Walk Moment

Well done setters! Nothing provoked the internal orchestra this week. Keep it up!

No comments: