Tuesday, 3 December 2024

Mastermind 2025 First Round Heat 15

Yeah, I’m sorry for anyone whose day was ruined by me no being able to post until now. Normally I do my write up early in the morning before I go to work, but I overslept this morning.

Charles Boden kicked us off last night with the solo career of Robbie Williams. It seems to me that we don’t see quite so much of the talented Mr. Williams now, but it’s worth noting just how big a star he was back in the day. Charles seemed pretty secure on the music but was caught out by the odd question on the videos and other periphera. That’s the thing about a Mastermind specialist round – if it could possibly be asked about something then you have to know it or learn it. Nothing to be ashamed with on 6, but unlikely to win.

Mark Kerr gave us a more traditional subject in the shape of C.S. Lewis’ The Chronicles of Narnia. Goodness me but I loved those books when I was in the primary school. However. . . that was half a century ago, and frankly, I didn’t remember very much about them – other than Eustace’s surname being Scrubb and gawd only knows why I remembered that. I thought Mark didn’t do at all badly with the set, but again, although 7 is perfectly respectable, it does leave you with a mountain to climb in the General Knowledge.

So we come to last night’s government health warning subject. I had answered Charles’ first question correctly and no others. Then I answered Mark’s first question and no others. Now I answered Matilda Makemson’s first on the Fauna of Madagascar and didn’t manage any others. What a subject. I don’t know how many species of creatures inhabit the place, but it’s a big old island. You had to feel for Matilda. She had a couple of wrong ‘uns and it certainly seemed to play on her mind as the round went on. Then to add insult to injury she had to endure Clive announcing both of her passes with the coda ‘You knew that, didn’t you?!” Fair play to Matilda, she didn’t say “Oh, sod off Clive!” as some of us might have been tempted to, but just nodded with a smile. Clive, mate, I know you’re trying to be kind, but please don’t. Matilda scored four.

It isn’t often that there is anything that even approaches controversy in Mastermind, but I was a little surprised in Roopam Carroll’s round on the Matrix Films. Roopam was going great guns until she was asked for the name of the award winning Australian costume designer credited on the first three films. She answered “. . . Kim . . . sorry.” Now had she just said “Kim” then I think Clive’s prompt of ‘more?’ would have been quite acceptable. However, for me the sorry seemed to mean ‘I’m sorry I don’t remember’ and I was a little surprised that he gave the prompt after. It’s a marginal call and I do not for one moment blame Roopam or taking advantage and giving the right answer, and fair play, she kicked in the best specialist round of the night with 9 and no passes.

You know me by now. I like it when a contender can put adversity behind them and whack in a good GK round, so I was very pleased to see Matilda Makemson manage to do just that. She scored a double figure round to finish with fourteen.

This looked even better as Charles in his round scored 8 which meant that he too finished with fourteen.

So we came to the business end of the competition. If you’re only two off the lead at the turnaround then you have a chance. Mike whacked in his own double figure round to at least give himself a chance. 17 meant that Roopam would need 9 to win outright, however the fact that Mike didn’t incur any passes made this look just a little more tricky.

Not that it appeared to affect Roopam. Without going quite at express pace she quite easily broke the tape with time enough to add a couple more correct answers to finish with her own 10 to finish with 19. My daughter Phillippa doesn’t often watch the show with me, but she was there last night, and she complained that Clive accepted Alto for Contralto. I’ll be honest, I thought this was okay, but it didn’t matter because Roopam was already in the winner’s enclosure.

Well done Roopam! Best of luck in your semi.

The Details

Charles Boden

The Solo Career of Robbie Williams

6

0

8

0

14

0

Mike Kerr

“The Chronicles of Narnia” by C.S. Lewis

7

0

10

0

17

0

Matilda Makemson

The Fauna of Madagascar

4

2

10

1

14

3

Roopam Carroll

The Matrix Films

9

0

10

1

19

1

No comments: