Tuesday 5 November 2024

University Challenge 2025 - First Round - London School of Economics v Leicester

The Teams

London School of Economics (LSE)

Albert Nyang Ying Zhi

Grant Dalton

Sebastian Bramley (Capt.)

Christina Zhiang

Leicester

Noah Lister

Greg Beeden

George Gowland (Capt.)

Edward Owen-Shah

I knew that Mackenzie King was the PM of Canada at the start of WWII

so came in a little bit faster for the first starter than Grant Dalton of LSE. This earned the Londoners a set of bonuses on electric batteries. We both took a full house and I took an early honorary lap of honour. Honorary? Well, I’m not well, you know. Again it was Grant Dalton who was first in for the next starter when it became clear that the answer was going to be he Commonwealth. So this earned the LSE questions on E. (Economics, that is).They duly took a full house. Me? – well. When asked for a number value I usually go for zero and it brought me more than zero again. Albert Nyang came in way too early before the next starter became obvious. It’s a great question – many people know that Uranus’ moons are named after characters in Pope and characters in Shakespeare – but of them all, only Ariel is a character in both. Good stuff. George Gowland opened his team’s account with this one. The Polish sculptor Magdalena Abakanowicz – no, me neither – brought 1 correct answer on a gettable set. For the picture starter we saw a picture of the George Cross and were asked on which flag it featured. Too easy for Noah Lister who won the buzzer race to answer Malta. Three more flags featuring dragons did not sadly include Wales or Bhutan and once again Leicester only took one of them. The next question about a TV show seemed unfathomable until the title of an episode– The Prisoner of Benda – launched a buzzer race to answer Futurama. George Gowland won that one. Bonuses on fictional artists brought two correct answers. This gave Leicester a narrow lead of 55 – 45 as we closed in on ten minutes.

Madha and the Musandam Governorate are exclaves of Oman. I didn’t know that, but Grant Dalton did. The second Scottish war of independence brought the bonus that LSE needed to retake the lead. The fashion designer who passed away in 2022 had to be Vivienne Westwood for the next starter. LSE skipper Sebastian Bramley thought so and he was right. Bonuses on insects brought LSE nowt. The economics starter was easy meat for the LSE’s Albert Nyang who buzzed in very quickly with Ceteris Paribus. Well, what else? The film and TV work of Alice Birch provided a full house which stretched the LSE’s lead. I was pleased when mass extinction in the next starter gave me Triassic, confirmed when the start of the age of dinosaurs was also mentioned. Albert Nyang took his second starter with that one. LSE took one bonus on the netball world cup and his took us up to the music starter. A wee snatch of Cream led Noah Lister to identify the guitar work of Eric Slowhand Clapton. Leicester did not manage to identify any of the inspirational Chicago and delta bluesmen in the bonuses. When it became obvious that the next starter was looking for The Marriage of Figaro George Gowland buzzed in with the correct answer. Shorter words that can be made using any of the letters from Love Island – which I’m told is a popular TV show – provided Leicester with no answers and it was at this point that I felt that their chances were receding quite quickly. Nobody got the next starter which had clues pointing to the word elephant. Christina Zhiang recognised the work of Ursula LeGuin which meant that every member of the LSE had answered at least 1 starter. A rapid full house on South America meant that they led by 135 to 75. One foot in round two and at least the big toe of another.

Saturated fats gave Noah Lister the next starter. Flags in formula 1 provided a surprisingly tough set of bonuses and Leicester failed to add to their score with them. Sebastian Bramley knew that the former name of Harare was Salisbury for the next starter. Presidents of the Royal Society saw the LSE only manage 1 bonus, but Leicester just were not going to be able to bridge the gap. Albert Nyang identified a wee splodge of Van Gogh for the second picture starter. They took two bouses on other artists’ paintings featuring Autumn leaves. Albert Nyang took another starter with Samurai. Victoria sensation novels brought two correct answers and widened the gap into triple figures. The next question related to Cologne Cathedral, and Grant Dalton buzzed in with the right answer, which brought up LSE’s double century, and they earned a full house on well known bird lovers. The clue was in the question for the next starter, with melittin being a constituent of bee venom. Either team had that. A great early buzz from Greg Beeden identified four as the only regnal number of two consecutive British kings – George and William. German cities with four letter names yielded just one bonus on a gettable set. Sadly George Gowland buzzed too early for the next starter which allowed Albert Nyang in with derby winner Auguste Rodin. A difficult set on poetic terms yielded two bonuses. For the quark question that followed Noah Lister ignored my advice to chose strange or charm, and was right to do so. The answer he gave, correctly was up. Mind you, so was the game as far as Leicester were concerned for the gong ended the contest. LSE won by 235 to 100.

Sorry, Leicester, but LSE were better on the buzzer, and they were better on the bonuses. LSE’s BCR was 67, while Leicester’s was 29. Sometimes it just isn’t your night.

Amol Watch

It was interesting that Amol called the Leicester captain ‘Mr. Gowland’ when Greg Beeden also said the answer at the same time as his skipper. He soon corrected himself, and called him George.

Interesting Fact That I Didn’t Already Know Of The Week

Benjamin Franklin invented the word battery for an electric battery.

Baby Elephant Walk Moment

The statistical measure of inequality described by the relationship A/A+B is known by what two-word term, where A is the area between perfect equality and the Lorenz Curve and B is the total area under the perfect equality line? I mean, come on, dum de dumdum dum dum dum dum dumdum.

Monday 4 November 2024

Mastermind First Round Heat 11

Good morning. We’re working through the first round at a pretty decent pace now, although I still think there’s something funny going on with the specialists. I’ll explain later.

Kaushik Bhattacharya kicked us off with the Sherlock Holmes stories. I feel I should tell you a story. Forty three years ago I took part in the inaugural Elthorne High School Mastermind competition, and I am far too vain not to admit that I won. A girl from the upper sixth, a year older than me, took Kaushik’s subject for specialist. She thought the subject was the four novels. The QM who set the questions thought that the subject was the four novels AND the more than fifty short stories. Result? Well, she didn’t do very well. It’s a massive subject that should come with a government health warning. Under those circumstances Kaushik’s 7 was not at all a bad score. But you felt for him a little as the higher scores piled on throughout the round.

Rachel Clapp’s was the first of these. She was answering on Sergei Rachmaninoff, and answering very well too, I might add. I had scored three on the Sherlock round and added another point here when I guessed Tchaikovsky for one of the answers. That was me done, but Rachel wasn’t, and by the end of the round I felt that her 9 would be one of the highest specialist scores in the show.

It wouldn’t be the highest, though. Her score was beaten by teacher – and latest recipient of the curse of support from the Clark sofa – Laura Rutherford. Laura was answering on “The West Wing.” You know, I still hear some people pour scorn on specialist rounds based on TV shows. All I can say is, if you think a round about a TV series that lasts many seasons and has many episodes is easy – you try it yourself! Laura did brilliantly, and scored 11, only really let down by a longish pause before answering on one of the questions.

Finally school administrator John Harden answered on Red Rum. I remember the day that the horse won his third Grand National – I was on a family visit to the National Railway Museum in York, and as we returned to the station to catch the train back to Kings Cross the news stands we passed all had the news of the win plastered over them. John’s round was brilliant. He too had a longish pause on one question, but got them all right to score 13. Which prompts my earlier comment about the specialist rounds. A fortnight ago we saw a perfect round from John Robinson on Futurism for which he scored 12. He hardly paused at all. Yet John H – and this is no criticism of him whatsoever – paused a little yet scored 13.

Well, it set up an interesting final round, that’s for sure. Kaushik, as all contenders must, gave it a lash, but the questions really didn’t seem to fall kindly for him. He ended with 12 points.

How must it feel to have a very good specialist round, as had Rachel, and find yourself four points adrift at half time? Well, she battled through her round, but it was fairly obvious that she was not going to be able to muster the kind of score to be able to open the corridor of doubt for the last two contenders. Rachel finished with 16.

So, Laura and John presented two different styles of answering in their GK rounds. Laura adopted the tactic of firing out the answer as quickly as she could after the question had been asked. Don’t knock it – I used such a tactic myself. Well, for me it wasn’t so much a tactic as force of habit. I have always been a blurter out, and I probably always will be. It took Laura into double figures for the round and she finished with 11 and no passes for a total of 22 and no passes. That would have been good enough to win quite a few of the shows we’ve seen this year.

John’s tactic was far more measured. Think about the question for a split second or more, then give a reasoned answer. Again, don’t knock it if it brings success. John needed it to bring at least 9 and no passes in order to force a tie break. But he took passes, and that meant he needed to win outright by scoring 10. At one point it looked by no means certain, but John carried on and in the end scored his own 11 to leave a little bit of daylight between himself and Laura. Honours even on the tactical front.

I must mention John’s very moving piece to camera. John explained that his wife had forced him to enter. He also explained that she had passed away before he made this appearance. Well, John, I am sure that I have never met either of you, but I hope you will forgive me for saying I am sure that she would be proud of you. I sincerely wish you every success in the semi.

Kaushik Bhattacharya

The Sherlock Holmes Stories of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

7

0

5

3

12

3

Rachel Clapp

Sergei Rachmaninoff

9

0

7

2

16

2

Laura Rutherford

Aaron Sorkin’s “The West Wing”

11

0

11

0

22

0

John Harden

Red Rum

13

0

11

2

24

2

Tuesday 29 October 2024

University Challenge 2025 - First Round - Leeds v. Edinburgh

The Teams

Leeds

Finn Thompson

Ingrid Banerjee Marvin

Alex Tan (Capt.)

Jayan Patel

Edinburgh

David Alton

Jess Mellor

Greg Myles (Capt.)

Caitlin Self

You had to wait with the first starter of the evening. We were looking for a weather phenomenon and when we were finally given the clue – Diane Fossey (Bob to her mates?) it was Greg Myles who won the buzzer race to identify mists. Film soundtracks composed by Jonny Greenwood got Edinburgh off to the best of starts with a full house. Did you know that the Florentine Codex is all about the Aztecs? I guessed it and so, I guess, did Greg Myles. The 1924 UK General Election slowed Edinburgh down somewhat, and they managed just 1 bonus. Algorithms to produce random numbers stumped all of us for the next starter. Greg Myles took his third starter with the words nit, not nut – which can be sung to the tune of Neil Diamond’s Song Sung Blue as it happens. Gawd knows how I guessed magnetic flux for the first bonus on magnetism but I was happy to take the money and run, er, stagger, off on my lap of honour around the Clark sofa. I also took the last bonus with Faraday meaning I got as many bonuses on this as Edinburgh. So to the picture round and a photo of a rack and pinion gearing system. Jayan Patel opened the Leeds account with that one. More gearing systems brought two bonuses. A very quick buzz from David Alton identified the Art movement Dada to bring a set of bonuses on the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. I remember watching the movie and somehow feeling it ought to have been better than it was. Eventually Edinburgh managed a full house and this meant that they led by 80 – 20 at just over the 10 minute mark.

Anna Bijns helped establish the vernacular literary tradition in Dutch apparently. Finn Thompson didn’t seem to have much confidence in this as an answer, but it was right. This brought Leeds bonuses on pairs of names differing only in their first letter. They gave one correct answer. David Alton untangled some gobbledygook to come up with the theory of General Relativity for the next starter. The artist Douglas Who (Gordon) brought a full house of bonuses for Edinburgh. Jess Mellor came in very quickly for the music starter, identifying the dulcet tones of double Eurovision winner Loreen, after whom the malt loaf was named, I believe. More artists who won the Eurovision on significant anniversaries brought two correct answers, but shame for missing out on Dana International, though. Nobody knew that Mr. Bumble thought that the law is an ass. For the next starter Leeds skipper Alex Tan knew James II and earned his team a set on esters. No, Rantzen wasn’t one of them. Only one was taken. They were going to need to do better than this if they were to have a chance of coming back. Now, if you get asked a question about quarks, mentally flip a coin. Heads strange, tails charm. This time it was strange as Finn Thompson confirmed. 2 bonuses were taken on Australia. Nobody could take the next starter on various terms for fish sauce. This meant that Edinburgh led by 125 to 65 as we approached the 20 minute mark.

Alex Tan knew that Prince Edward Island is the smallest Canadian Province. Bonuses on Angels in America brought 1 correct answer. So to the second picture starter, a still showing Gregory Peck as Atticus Finch in To Kill A Mockingbird. Caitlin Self won the buzzer race to give the answer. Other courtroom dramas brought two bonuses. Ingrid Banerjee Marvin identified the Bloomsbury group for the next starter. The late Alexander McQueen brought two correct answers. Jayan Patel knew the Cardinals American sports teams and this gave them a set on Latin American dances, of which they knew one. This burst of Leeds scoring had pulled them up to within striking distance of Edinburgh, just a full house behind. They were even closer after Finn Thompson correctly answered that Swansea were one of the non London, Manchester or Liverpool teams to win the League Cup this century. British birds with reduplicative scientific names – pica pica for example – failed to bring any more points. -That’s quite close enough – said Jess Mellor – metaphorically – as she took the next starter with the film Jojo Rabbit. Cultural references of the word rose brought two correct answers and Leeds once more would need at least two visits to the table to take the lead. Neither team could do it with the next starter. Now, if you’re asked for a french cemetery, if you give the answer Pere Lachaise you’ll be right a lot more often than you’ll be wrong. Greg Myles did just that, and that gap was stretching again. Edinburgh didn’t get any of the bonuses on canals, but it didn’t matter. There just wasn’t enough time left for Leeds. Especially when Greg Myles capped an effective evening’s work by answering with genes for the next starter. Australian actor David Gulpilil was the subject of the bonuses, but Amol didn’t have time to complete the first question. In the end Edinburgh won by 175 to 125.

Leeds had a relatively modest BCR of 42 compared with Edinburgh’s 64, and essentially that is why Leeds never quite got onto terms with them. Will they make the repechage? On balance I’d say no, but then what do I know?

Amol Watch

Kudos to Amol for not laughing when Leeds confused Rosa Luxembourg with Ethel Rosenberg. I can only imagine what a vintage Jeremy Paxman might have made of that one.

Interesting Fact That I Didn’t Already Know Of The Week

The chough has a scientific name meaning flame-coloured raven. Choughing hell!

Baby Elephant Walk Moment

I need the two word name of a specific scientific theory here. Using gamma-ray emissions from iron-57, vibrated by a loudspeaker cone 22cm above a detector, the Pound-Rebka Experiment was an experimental test of which specific theory’s prediction that the gravitational field will affect the frequency of protons? Dum de dumdum dum dum dum dum dumdum.

Mastermind 2025 First Round Heat 10

Well, dearly beloved, a very interesting show this one was. What made it so? All shall be revealed.

Meanwhile, let’s begin with the specialist round. Braving the curse of the Clark sofa was Susan Cook. I currently work for the NHS, and so does Susan. Now, my banker subject for the evening was Susan’s, the poetry of John Keats. Keats is the first poet whose work I absolutely loved, and I still know it well enough to say with confidence that Susan was given a tough round. Without wishing to be ungallant, though, I have to say that judging by a couple of the questions to which she gave wrong answers, perhaps her prep was just a little undercooked. She scored four. I scored three lonely points, which remained just as lonely by the end of the specialists.

Next was Juliet Harris. Now, I have to say that there seemed to be nothing undercooked about her preparation for the round. Basically anything to do with PJ Harvey was fair game in this round, and Juliet was equal to pretty much all of it. Yeah, she dropped one or two, but then perfect rounds aren’t just good, they’re exceptional. In the end she scored 9 and looked certain to feature in the shake up for the podium places.

Right – here’s a question for you. Which would you say is the rarest British broadcast quiz double? Personally I believe that it’s the UC and Mastermind double. It’s only been done once, by our own Stephen Follows. We’ve had other Mastermind champs who have done very well in UC without winning it, and UC champs who have gone as far as the final of Mastermind too, but landing the double has only been done once. So I was delighted to see Justin Lee who was a key member of the this year’s UC champs from Imperial having a bash. Answering on perennial crowd pleaser Emperor Henry IV he equalled the leader with 9.

I think that the matchmaker for last night had a bit of a sense of humour, since our final contender was also a University Challenger, Lewis Jones, captain of the 2023 Sheffield team eliminated in the Repechage. Answering on the films of David Fincher Lewis did not have a great round, scoring five, but crucially he did not pass, giving himself at least the ghost of a chance.

Susan Cook, realistically, did not have even that being five points behind as we changed ends. So I was impressed with the way she returmed to the chair and delivered a double figure GK round with 10 to take her to fourteen.

I have to say that this was rather put into shadow by what followed. Lewis Jones returned to the chair and whacked in what I felt to be easily one of the finest GK rounds that we’ve seen all series. Lewis snapped out his answers, and didn’t have many wrong’uns either. A magnificent fourteen took his total to 19 and no passes. That meant that anyone wishing to beat him outright would need to hit the psychologically daunting target of 20.

Juliet didn’t manage it. She came close to joining Lewis at the top, but she just ran out of time. In the end she added 9 to her total for a good 18.

This left just Justin Lee. He needed 11 to win outright. To be honest, I think he was just a little off the pace in his GK round, never looking as comfortable as Lewis had. But then Justin is a UC champion, an accolade that they don’t give away with a litre of petrol, and he battled on to score the 10 he needed to equal Lewis. All of which gave us that rarest of rara aves, a tie break. Comparing both contenders’ GK rounds I felt that Lewis, going second, might have just too much firepower for Justin and essentially that’s the way it worked out. Lewis managed to correctly answer four of the five questions while Justin took two.

Very well played, gentlemen. Hard lines to Justin, but hey, you’re a young chap. If you really want to do the double you’ve plenty of time. Congratulations to Lewis. With GK like that, if you can get the right specialist subject, I’d say that you’re one to watch. Best of luck in the semis.

The Details

Susan Cook

The Poetry of John Keats

4

0

10

0

14

0

 

 

Juliet Harris

P.J. Harvey

9

0

9

0

18

0

 

 

Justin Lee

The Holy Roman Emperor Henry IV

9

0

10

0

19

0

2

0

Lewis Jones

The Films of David Fincher

5

0

14

0

19

0

4

0

Wednesday 23 October 2024

University Challenge First Round - St. Andrews v Cardiff

The Teams

St. Andrews

Diane Buffet-Mogel

George Capell

Freddie Skerrett (Capt)

Tom Rosas

Cardiff

Kyle Gilbert

Rosalie Tarsala

Conor Boyling (Capt)

Henrik Holm

So, here we go, dearly beloved. Not long now until the first round is concluded. Scotland played Wales – sort of the land of MY fathers versus Land of My Fathers (Hen Wlad Fy Nhadau).

The good old Count of Monte Cristo set off a buzzer race won by Diane Buffet-Mogel for St. Andrews to take the first starter. Species native to particular islands or archipelagos. They took two and could have had a full house, with the Tasman Devil being ruled incorrect as it is the Tasmanian Devil. Them’s the breaks. The only British Overseas Territory which does not incorporate the Union Jack into its own flag is Gibraltar – and Tom Rosas buzzed in for that one. Helen’s bust of Canova of Troy – sorry, I’ll read that again – Canova’s Bust of Helen of Troy brought two more bonuses. Once Amol gave the answer of the physicist Mach to the next question it made sense, but none of us had it. The next starter suddenly became obvious and Rosalie Tarsala won the race to give the answer of Masala. Bonuses on alterative methods of musical notation did not, surprisingly include the dumdedum method I use in these reviews, but still brought two bouses, and Cardiff were up and running. So to the picture starter. We were shown a map of a shipping route and asked for the American city at the northern end of the route. Mob – isle said Kyle Gilbert. Mob EEL Amol corrected him, but gave him the points. Quite right too. More places linked by roro ferries brought just one correct answer. For the next starter Asuka sounded Japanese to me. It did to Kyle Gilbert too and we were both right. British monarchs and languages meant that Cardiff led by 55 to 40 at the 10 minute mark.

With the next starter you had to wait, but as soon as it mentioned it was a composer who wrote a famous work about a swiss folk hero it was obvious the answer was Rossini, yet both teams rather sat on their buzzers until Henrik Holm buzzed in with the right answer. A full house on catastrophes was well taken.Various uses of the Greek letter gamma saw captain Conor Boyling take another consecutive starter for Cardiff. Vahanas – that is the animal carriers of various avatars of Hindu deities brought two bonuses and took the Cardiff score to 100. Epistemology of the Closet allowed Diane Buffet-Mogel to elbow St. Andrews’ way back into the competition and earned a set on oe act plays. They took two. For the music starter that followed we heard the sound of Green Onions, by Booker T and the MGs. Rosalie Tarsala had Booker T but knew she was wrong with Washington. St. Andrews couldn’t take advantage and at least Miss Tarsala got an ‘I’m sorry, Rosalie “ from Amol. Both teams sat on their buzzers a little for the next starter. When you hear ‘game’ and ‘bamboo’ you slam the buzzer down and answer Mahjong. Freddie Skerrett took that one. This earned the music bonuses. Three more fantastic tracks from Stax records – I mean, I’m a Motown man myself, but these were all great. These largely passed St. Andrews by. No one knew the DICE method of something or other. The Astronomy starter that followed meandered its weary way along until it became obvious that the answer was great wall. Conor Boyling won that buzzer race, to win the dubious honour of a set of bonuses on URLs.Two correct answers were enough to take Cardiff to 120 and to stretch the lead to fifty points. Did you know that Alfonso V of Aragon was Alfonso the Magnanimous? Freddie Skerrett did. Or worked it out from the clue – bloomin’ good shout whichever way. US film maker John Waters brought them a full house which halved the gap as we approached the 20 minute mark. Cardiff still led by 120 – 95.

George Capell picked up a reference to the Turner prize for the next starter. European countries whose names start with different letters in English and German – Germany being an example – did few favours to St. Andrews since they only managed the 1. However the gap was down to one starter. A starter which was taken by George Capel with the answer Mercosur. Contemporary economics sadly means as much to me as contemporary dance but the set was grist to the George Capel mill and he took a full house on the bonus set. Blake’s picture of Milton showed both teams a clean pair of heels for the next starter. Henrik Holm took the next starter with the word base which earned Cardiff the picture bonuses. 1 bonus identifying a poet from a picture levelled the scores with just five minutes left. As soon as Nunavut was mentioned for the next starter Rosalie Tarsala won the buzzer race to say the indigenous people involved were Inuit. Numbered physical laws earned me a lap of honour for Kepler’s first law of planetary motion. Back came St. Andrews, knowing various places associated with silver mining. Monochrome paintings brought one bonus – one more than I had, to be honest. A good old UC chestnut asked if arranged alphabetically, who comes first in the Old Testament? Kyle Gilbert took the starter with Aaron. Words ending with – ara brought two correct answers and a narrow lead, with little time left. Nobody knew the 1970s wrestler, giant hogweed, for the next answer. Conor Boyling knew the number of seats needed in a US election to win a majority, and this with hindsight was the decisive moment of the match. Bonuses on Nigel Lawson brought just one bonus. Didn’t matter. St. Andrews were going to need at least two visits to the table and there was only time for one left. Which was taken by Henrik Holm anyway, with Vivaldi’s four seasons – salt, mustard, vinegar and pepper. There was just time for Cardiff to take one bonus on nebulae. At the gong they had won by 200 to 145.

A good match that I enjoyed. Both teams had BCRs of 58, but the best buzzing came from Cardiff which won them the match. I hope that St. Andrews’ score will be enough to ear a repechage slot – I’d say that the coin is on the air on that one.

Amol Watch

Again, I’m on Amol’s side when he ruled out the Tasman Devil for the Tasmania Devil – with the proviso that if you are going to insist that only a right answer is right, then you have to do it with everything. I’m pretty much on his side as well when he castigated St. Andrews for not recognising the Stax records too.

Interesting Fact That I Didn’t Already Know Of The Week

Masala is a term also used in Indian cinema to indicate a film that mixes several genres.

Baby Elephant Walk Moment

In electronics what four letter term denotes the central terminal in a bipolar junction transistor coming between the collector and emitter? In chemistry Bronsted and Lowry used this word to refer to a . . . and at this point Henrik Holm buzzed in with the answer. Dum de dumdum dum dum dum dum dumdum.

Monday 21 October 2024

Mastermind First Round Heat 9

Well, this was an episode of Mastermind that really showed us both ends of the spectrum, certainly during the specialist rounds anyway. We’ll come to that.

Kicking off the proceedings was Anthony Smith. As soon as he announced that his specialist subject was the Emperor Claudius, I thought to myself – fill yer boots ‘ere, son -. Basically ever since my mate Alfie Dilieto played Patrick Stewart’s son in “I Claudius” I loved firstly the TV series and secondly the two Claudius books by Robert Graves. Anthony’s round proved to be pretty testing and I thought that he did well to score 8. As for me, I scored 6, which is more than my whole specialist aggregate for quite a few of the previous shows in this series.

Kal Dixit followed, answering on The Watergate Scandal. The plain fact of the matter is that Kal scored 3. We’ve talked before, you and I, about the factors which can contribute to a contender having a low score in a specialist round – there are actually quite a few. Only Kal could tell us which applied in this case. To me sitting at home it looked as if one early question where she just couldn’t get the name needed for the answer past the tip of her tongue ruined the rest of the round for her. Well, it happens. Look, it’s only Mastermind, it’s not the end of the world. I got the plumbers question to add a point to the aggregate.

Following Kal we had Caroline Grogan answering on Andrew Lloyd Webber’s The Phantom of the Opera. I’ve never watched it, but I remember Steve Harley having a hit with the title song and that took my aggregate to 9. Coincidentally 9 was the total that Caroline finished the round with. Good stuff, and let’s be fair, that’s the kind of score which can be the springboard to a heat win in this series.

How, I wondered, would John Robinson, our final contender, cope with the curse of the Clark sofa? For yes, John is a teacher. The answer to that question being incredibly well. John was answering on Futurism. On the one hand this scuppered my chances of getting at least one question in every round of last night’s show right. On the other hand it brought him a magnificent 12 from 12. And let’s be honest, he went so quickly I’m not sure he could possibly have squeezed in another question, which is all grist to the mill of my contention that the specialist rounds have been somehow contrived to be lower scoring this series.

I felt for Kal Dixit, having to return to the chair immediately after watching that bravura and frankly almost effortless performance from John. But I needn’t have worried. Whatever Kal was feeling about her specialist round she managed to put it behind her and scored a very competitive double figure round of 10. A show of some determination, that, I felt.

In another show Anthony’s 8 in the SS would have meant he was close to the lead, but in this one he began four points behind. So it was imperative for him to keep his head and stack up the highest score that he could manage. And he managed pretty well, too. Anthony also achieved a double figure round of 10, which put him up to 18. Probably not close to a winning score for this heat, but enough to make the last two contenders think.

Caroline Grogan produced our third double figure GK round in a row and it seemed to me that Clive had one of those rounds where he gets into the swing of things too and fires in the questions with a little more steam. Caroline finished the round with 11. This meant that John would at least have to cross the corridor of doubt for part of his round.

There are worse places to be than the Mastermind chair when you need 8 points and less than five passes for a win. However, you do still have to answer the questions. It’s all in the eye of the beholder and ear of the behearer but I thought that John was given the hardest of the 3 GK rounds and he still managed a good 12. As I was listening to his answers I thought to myself – yes, you are a quizzer, my boy, and very much a contender.” He is too. He scored 12 for twenty four, the highest for a few weeks.

John, I’m not going to curse you any further by tipping you for success, but I wish you good luck in the semis and I shall be watching your progress with interest.

The Details

Anthony Smith

The Emperor Claudius

8

0

10

0

18

0

Kal Dixit

The Watergate Scandal

3

1

10

0

13

1

Caroline Grogan

Anrew Lloyd Webber’s “The Phantom of the Opera”

9

2

11

3

20

5

John Robinson

Futurism

12

0

12

0

24

0

Tuesday 15 October 2024

University Challenge 2025 Round 1 - Exeter College, Oxford v. Christ's College , Cambridge

The Teams

Exeter, Oxford

Edie Allden

Benjamin Gray

Schuyler Colfax (Capt.)

Daniyal Vemuri

Christ’s, Cambridge

Anniko Firman

Brendan Bethlehem

Oscar Despard(Capt.)

Linus Luu

Second Oxbridge match of the season, dearly beloved. Just before we start, I don’t normally comment on contestants’ names, but I’m moved to ask whether Exeter captain Schuyler Colfax is a descendant of Ulysses S. Grant’s first vice president who shared his name?

Let us begin, then. I’ll be honest, the only female 19th century pianist I know of is Clara Schuman, which is just as well since she was the answer to the first starter. Brendan Bethlehem knew it, and this earned bonuses on pairs of years with reordered digits eg 1066 and 1660.A nice set which brought a full house and a name check for the most famous man to be named after 3 sheepdogs, Bonnie Prince Charlie. My internal orchestra struck up after the words - Motile versions of which cellular structure – and when it stopped Oscar Despard had given the correct answer of cilia. Imrie or Johnson? Didn’t say. German language films that take place at least in part before the reunification provided us both with nowt. A quote from the rejection letter of a famous work of fiction had to refer to Proust. Oscar Despard certainly felt so and he took the starter. Provitamins – as opposed to amateurvitamins – brought two correct answers. The opening paragraph of a work originally written in French was recognised by Benjamin Gray as the opening of Le Petit Prince. Three short extracts in their original languages put Exeter’s collective translation skills to the test and brought them two correct answers, and they were only a tense error away from a full house. We were just shy of the 20 minute mark and Christ’s led by fifty five to twenty.

Brendan Bethlehem came in too early for the next starter on a city before the words Mons Meg gave Edinburgh to some of us, but not Exeter. Nothing daunted Brendan Bethlehem buzzed early again and this time was right on the money that Teresa of Avila and Catherine of Siena were given the title of Doctor of the Church. For the bonuses Christ’s managed to identify two names from the titles of poems. Daniyal Vemuri dredged up the term interpreter from computing to pull his team back into the game. A full house about quotations on the subject of violence proved a most timely boost to their fortunes. It was worth hanging on during the next question about a prestigious American prize, for when it mentioned that one recipient designed buildings it became obvious this was the Pritzker, and Oscar Despard showed the quickest finger to win the ensuing buzzer race. Venetian artists brought just the one bonus. The Christ’s captain was on a little bit of a roll, as he took the next bonus on a German chappie who studied serfdom in Russia. Beats working for a living, I suppose. Highest mountains completely within one country brought two correct answers. At this point Amol unleashed a little encouragement upon Exeter. Maybe it worked too as Benjamin Gray recognised the work of Saint-Saens for the music starter. The team managed one bonus. Bejamin Gray took a second consecutive starter with Felix Klein.Pascal’s Triangles yielded two correct answers and the gap was starting to look distinctly bridgeable. So Brenda Bethlehem widened it again by answering that the Peljesac Bridge is in Croatia. One bonus on operettas meant that Christ’s led by 120 – 80 on the cusp of 20 minutes.

Schuyler Colfax won the race to answer that the fruit at the heart of the Atalanta myth is the apple. Porfirio Diaz brought them two bonuses to narrow the gap to 20. Bejamin Gray came in too early and lost five allowing Brendan Bethlehem to join up the dots of the clues and give the correct answer of the tooth, the whole tooth and nothing but the tooth. Rocket fuel bonuses helped Christ’s rocket away again. So to the second picture starter. Now look, if it’s an early photograph of a ballerina, it’ll be Anna Pavlova. It just will, alright? Brendan Bethlehem took that one. Other people who inspired the name of a food item surprisingly failed to include Ignacio Chilliconcarne but Christ’s still managed one of a difficult set. Nobody knew Nietzsche’s Twilight of the Idols (Billy, Eric and Bone.)It was nice to see Exeter starting to really sling some early buzzer. It didn’t work on the next starter as they lost five, but it was the right tactic I think. It allowed Anniko Firmin in for her first starter with velvet. The next starter, about Eisenstein’s use of montage, allowed Lius Luu I and that meant everyone in Exeter had correctly answered at least 1 starter. The term bottleneck as associated with population development proved strong contenders for the baby elephant walk moment. When I woke up, Christ’s had scored a full house and crossed the event horizon. A great UC special question on flags was taken by Brendan Bethlehem who was having a very good evening. Two bonuses on Natural History put Christ’s on the brink of a double century. Schuyler Colfax was first in to answer that Shakespeare’s Richard III keeps asking for a horse before he snuffs it. Early 20th century art took Exeter to 110. Another set and they’d have at least a chance of a repechage slot. Almost inevitably it was Brendan Bethlehem who took the next starter with octahedron. No, I don’t have the slightest idea what the question was actually about. That was it, no time for bonuses. Christ’s won by 205 to 110.

For the record Exeter had a BCR of 67. Pretty good, but it don’t mean a thing if you can’t win the race to answer the starters. Christ’s had a BCR of 58, but were clear winners on the buzzer.

Amol Watch

First encouragement to Exeter was timed at fifteen and a half minutes, which is fair.

Interesting Fact That I Didn’t Already Know Of The Week

Mount Kosciusko is in New South Wales. I knew it was in Australia, but not where.

Baby Elephant Walk Moment

Motile versions of which cellular structure are formed by a pair of microtubules surrounded by a ring of nine more pairs of microtubules. These structures are found in many cell types, but are abundant in the lining of the respiratory – and at this point Oscar Despard thankfully brought an end to the tedium by giving the correct answer. Dum de dumdum dum dum dum dum dumdum.